There is a sentence we hear in almost every first meeting: “The leads are coming in, but the salespeople say they are no good.” The marketing dashboard is green, the cost per lead is going down, and yet sales do not follow. In almost every case, the salespeople are not at fault: it is a problem in how the acquisition was designed.
The cost per lead trap
Cost per lead is a reassuring indicator. It is simple, it can be compared from one month to the next, and the ad platforms are very good at bringing it down. That is exactly where the trap closes: when you ask an algorithm for cheaper leads, it finds the people who fill in a form most easily. Not the ones who will buy.
A form pre-filled in two clicks, a very broad audience, a hook like “Win” or “Get it free”: all of this lowers the cost per lead. All of it also raises the proportion of people who do not even remember leaving their number when you call them back.
Cost per lead is an incomplete indicator. Alone, it rewards volume. It must be read next to what becomes of these leads.
Defining a good lead, with the salespeople
Before touching the campaigns, the first step is a conversation between marketing and sales. What is a good prospect for you? Generally, the answer comes down to four criteria:
- The need: the person has a real project.
- The role: they decide, or directly influence the decision.
- The means: their budget is compatible with your offer.
- The timing: their project plays out within a horizon you can serve.
These criteria seem obvious. Yet they are rarely written down, and almost never translated into the campaigns. As long as they are not, marketing and sales are not talking about the same lead.
Sorting before counting
Once the criteria are set, you can build an acquisition that sorts at every step, instead of accepting everything and then letting the salespeople sort on the phone.
The audience. A precise audience costs more per contact, but it contains fewer people who will never become customers. Excluding those who have already converted and those who do not match your area or your target, and tightening around the behaviors that announce a project, means accepting to pay a little more for much less waste.
The message. A good ad attracts the right people and repels the others. Clearly announcing a price range, a type of customer, a requirement, lowers the number of contacts and raises their quality. What looks like a loss is a free filter.
The form. This is the most underrated lever. Three or four well-chosen questions change everything: the goal, the role in the company, the budget range, the current situation. Every question added lowers the completion rate, that is true. Above all, it removes part of the contacts your teams would not have converted anyway, and it tells the salespeople who to call back first.
On Meta, the type of form chosen also matters. A form designed for volume is filled in within two seconds; a higher-intent form adds a verification step before sending. That small amount of friction is often the difference between a list of numbers and a list of prospects.
Teaching the algorithm what a good customer is
The ad platforms optimize what they are shown. If they only see completed forms, they will look for people who complete forms. If they see which of these leads became appointments, then customers, they can learn to look for those.
In concrete terms, this means feeding the status of the leads back to Meta and Google: qualified, appointment booked, customer signed. Meta’s Conversions API and Google’s offline conversion import serve this purpose. This chaining requires a minimum of organization, a CRM kept up to date and a shared identifier between the lead and the sale. It is often the project that pays off the most, because it changes what the machine looks for.
Callback speed
A detail that is not one: the delay between the moment someone leaves their details and the moment they are called back. A prospect contacted within the hour remembers their request and their desire. The same prospect, called back three days later, has had time to talk to a competitor, or to forget.
A good share of “bad” leads are actually leads called back too late. Before changing campaign, it is worth measuring this delay.
The indicators to follow instead
Cost per lead remains useful, provided it is surrounded:
- The share of qualified leads, according to the criteria defined with sales.
- The cost per qualified lead, which says what a useful contact really costs.
- The cost per opportunity, that is, per appointment or per proposal sent.
- The customer acquisition cost, which remains the only judge.
Take a fictional example. A campaign A produces leads twice as cheap as a campaign B. But only one lead in ten from campaign A is qualified, against one in three for campaign B. The qualified lead from campaign A then costs more than the one from campaign B, while the dashboard showed it as the winner. Without the second line, the wrong campaign would have been cut.
An example of a form that qualifies
For a business services offer, a form that sorts without discouraging can fit in four questions, in addition to the contact details:
- What is your main goal? With three or four proposed answers, matching what you know how to do. Those who do not recognize themselves flag it on their own.
- What is your role in the company? Executive, marketing lead, sales lead, other. You know before calling whether you are speaking to the decision maker.
- What budget are you considering? By ranges, never in a free field. A range is ticked without embarrassment; an exact amount makes people drop off.
- Where are you today? No action under way, managed in-house, provider in place. This answer alone prepares the first minute of the call.
With these four answers, the salesperson no longer discovers the person on the phone. They know who to call back first, what they will propose and which objections await them. The leads that do not match do not disappear: they are handled later, or nurtured with content, instead of taking up the best hour of the day.
What this changes for teams
An approach that sorts before counting produces fewer leads. This must be said clearly to management and to the teams before putting it in place, otherwise the first reaction will be to believe the campaigns have deteriorated. From there, you look at the curve of appointments and signatures.
What to remember
Lead volume is an easy goal to reach and easy to present. It is also the most misleading. A healthy acquisition is judged on the number of prospects your salespeople want to talk to, and on the cost of each customer signed.
This requires four things: a good lead defined with sales, campaigns that sort before counting, platforms that learn what a real customer is, and teams that call back fast. None of them is spectacular. Together, they change the nature of what you receive.
Want us to look at your own numbers?
45 minutes, free. We look at your campaigns, your numbers and your offer.